Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Letter from Minsk: Belarus- a country unspoilt by capitalism



This report of mine from Belarus, the European country that the neocons and the faux-left love to hate, appears in the new edition of the New Statesman.


The article is not available online yet, but here’s the first few paragraphs. You can order a copy of this week's New Statesman (or take out a subscription to the magazine) here.
UPDATE: You can now read the whole of the article, below, or at the New Statesman website.


Immaterial pearl


Belarus- Europe's 'last dictatorship'- is still unspoilt by capitalism, Neil Clark reports.

A woman sits bolt upright in the middle of the night. She jumps out of bed and rushes to the bathroom to look in the medicine cabinet. Then, she runs into the kitchen and opens the refrigerator. Finally, she dashes to the window and looks out into the street. Relieved, she returns to the bedroom. Her husband asks, “What's wrong with you?” “I had a terrible nightmare,” she says. “I dreamed we could still afford to buy medicine, that the refrigerator was absolutely full, and that the streets were safe and clean. I also dreamed that you had a job, that we could afford to pay our gas and electricity bills.”
“How is that a nightmare?” asks her husband. The woman shakes her head, “I thought the communists were back in power.”


That Bulgarian joke, as told by Maria Todorova in the Guardian and now doing the rounds across eastern europe, doesn’t work here in Minsk. This is a capital city where the streets are safe and clean, where ordinary people can still afford to buy medicine and basic foodstuffs and where the unemployment rate is less than 1 per cent. It’s the side of Belarus you won’t read much about.


After last month’s presidential elections, in which Alexander Lukashenko was re-elected to serve a fourth term with almost 80% of the vote- the arrest of opposition candidates and hundreds of their supporters led to the reappearance of the old ‘last dictatorship in Europe’ headlines. But shocking as the scenes of police beating protestors were, it’s a mistake to equate Belarus with Burma, or Lukashenko with Joseph Stalin.


Lukashenko’s rule is unquestionably authoritarian, as he has conceded, but his policies, which combine aspects of the old communist system – social security and full employment- with a mixed economy and greater personal freedoms than existed under the old Soviet Union, have proved genuinely popular with the majority of ordinary Belarusians, as his election results testify.


While other former Soviet Republics rushed to embrace capitalism following the fall of the Berlin Wall, privatising their state-owned enterprises and removing subsidies to industry and agriculture, Belarus kept the old collectivist flame alive. My guide book describes it as a country “so unspoilt by the trappings of western materialism that it’s very easy to feel a sense of having slipped into another time and dimension”.

Yet even here – a country where roughly 80 per cent of the economy is nationalised and statues of Lenin still adorn the streets – times are changing. Pressure from the IMF and Russia, and a desire to court the European Union among other reasons have led Belarus to embark on a major privatisation programme of its own, with around 90 per cent of state-owned enterprises earmarked for sale. Does the move mark the de facto end of Europe’s last socialist planned economy?



During a press conference at Belarus's wonderfully retro ministry of economy, where the BBC could quite happily have filmed the Life on Mars series, Nikolai Snopkov, the minister in charge of the department, denies that his country is changing course. "All the successful economic systems in the world are mixed systems. We are committed to combining the principle of the free market with social justice. The economy is not for itself: it has a human purpose." Asked if Belarus will roll back the state, he answers with a resounding "nyet".
Ukrainian rhapsody


Afterwards, we are taken to see one of the country's industrial gems - the enormous Belarusian Autoworks (BelAZ) factory in Zhodino. BelAZ, which launched in 1948, employs 12,000 people, and is the biggest producer of mining dump trucks in the world.


Our guide Natalia proudly escorts us round the factory museum, with its scale models of BelAZ vehicles. There is a photograph of a beaming Hugo Chávez, a strong ally of Luka­shenko (he recently said that Venezuela would supply Belarus with oil for the next 200 years), driving a BelAZ truck. This is more than just a company - it's an extended family. There is a sanatorium for the workers, two sports and fitness centres, and a cultural centre where a theatre collective plays. Such enterprises used to be common in eastern Europe before 1989 - but economic reform put a stop to all that.


On our return to Minsk, we find the bars and cafés full of well-dressed young people. Aggression and public displays of drunkenness are refreshingly absent from the streets. Outside the state opera (cheapest tickets US$2), we meet an Irish restaurant owner who has emigrated to Belarus. "This is the place," he says. "The economy is booming and there's a real vibe. My son and I went to Ukraine recently and everyone was saying to us: 'Can we have the Belarus president in charge here for a year?'"


It's not difficult to see why. Unlike Ukraine and Russia, Belarus's economy is not dominated by billionaire oligarchs. There is no underclass: according to UN figures, Belarus has one of the lowest levels of social inequality in the world. Lukashenko wins elections not through fear, but because he has delivered social protection and rising standards of living. Growth now stands at 7 per cent.


The danger, some feel, is that a move towards a more market-oriented economy will destroy these achievements, and leave Belarusians sharing the same bitter-sweet jokes as their fellow eastern Europeans.


4 comments:

Anonymous said...

The official numbers often do not match reality. I'm not a social scientist, and I don't know how the unemployment numbers are collected, but I know people who last year were still employed, but at half wages. And then laid off. And told the stories of many others in the same boat.

The opposition skews the numbers as well.

Getting at the truth in Belarus is difficult at best, but in most cases impossible.

I apologize for remaining anonymous, but I wish to continue doing humanitarian work in Belarus, and don't want to risk the opinion expressed here to attract unwanted attention...

David Lindsay said...

The Harry's Place thread on this article was hilarious. What a bitter lot. Especially Kamm. Honestly, is he really saying that if what he said were true, then Jason Cowley would still be employing you, as Natalie Hanman also does, as Fraser Nelson also does, as Alan Rusbridger also does, and so on?

Including The American Conservative. When was Kamm last published in America? He is reduced to calling TAC "outside the mainstream" because, er, it does not employ him. Oh, and because it turns a profit. Unlike the only outfit with Kamm on the payroll. And when did even that ever have him in the print edition?

He should instead be asking himself why they do not employ him. You have never been party to lying this country into war, nor has the NUJ ever been after you for criminally harassing another journalist. And the "left-wing" Harry's Place boys in general should be asking themselves why your contributions, not theirs, are printed in the Guardian and the New Statesman.

Is it just the spectacle of their own past lives in the Brezhnev-era kitsch of the Lukashenko Government? Or in the spotty, unelectable adolescents who comprise the "opposition", admittedly a lot better, since merely harmless, than the neighbouring giant's Stalinists, National Bolsheviks, Islamist terrorists, and anti-urban, anti-industrial, anti-scientific fantasists who are all cheered on simultaneously by the New Cold Warriors?

The Holy See identifies as a bridge between Eastern and Western Christendom the last nation in Europe west of the Russian border to identify entirely in terms other than those of rootless neoliberal stupefaction, promiscuity, usury and warmongering. Was the Papacy notable for its close relationship with the Soviet regime, such that it would wish to maintain such ties with that regime's last vestige in Europe?

sgmissfoxy said...

very interesting your job on a country development.

Encounters Nepal said...

Everest Base Camp Trekking often touted as one of the most beautiful of trekking trips in the whole world and rightly it is. Located at the lap of world's highest peak, Everest Base Camp (EBC) is rewarded as the best trip Nepal has to offer. Since 1920, Mt Everest has captivated intrepid men and women. There were some exploits of legends like Sir Edmund Hillary, George Mallory and Tenzing Norgay Sherpa to put the mighty mountains on the map. Thousands of adventurers followed them making huge sacrifices. EBC Trek is designed to fulfill the dream of many people to experience the historic route to the base of world's highest peak. Since the beginning, Everest Base Camp Route has gained massive popularity and a lot of appreciation. The highlights of Everest Base Camp Trekking are the stunning views of Mount Everest, legendary Sherpa culture, wonderful Namche Bazaar, Tengboche Monastery, the best viewpoint of Kalapatthar, and beautiful Chhukung valley among many others. We gradually ascend through the wonderful Sherpa villages enjoying the magnificent Himalayan scenery, wildlife and visit a number of Buddhist Monasteries. EBC Trek culminates with a fine opportunity to trek to both EBC and nearby peak of Kalapatthar (5545m) for spectacular views of the Everest. Savoring the high mountain views with the unique and life defining journey, EBC trip can be combined with Gokyo Chola Pass Trek, or Everest Three Passes packages as well, making the journey bit more challenging and rewarding too. Encounters Nepal has carefully devised an itinerary with a number of rest days that offers an exceptional way to acclimatize safely. Having had hit the Himalayan Trails since so long, we have learned never to rush a trek to altitude in the Himalaya. Taking an extra few days makes all the difference to really being able to enjoy the trek and trekking in Nepal.