Monday, September 08, 2008

Wisdom Teeth


This article of mine on the state of NHS dentistry appears in the New Statesman.

patient: How much to have this tooth pulled?
dentist: £180.
patient: £180 for just a few minutes' work?
dentist: I can extract it very slowly if you like.


Jokes about going to the dentist used to be about the pain of tooth extraction, but in 21st-century Britain they're more likely to be about the pain to our wallets. An estimated one in five people in Britain is deterred from going to the dentist because of the cost; eight million of us have refused a course of treatment because it was too expensive. The seemingly inexorable decline of affordable National Health Service dentistry, and the growth of private practice (the most expensive in Europe), have certainly hurt our pockets.

But could it be that, after years of decline, the tide is turning? You wouldn't think so, judging by newspaper headlines reacting to newly published figures showing that more than one million patients in England have lost access to free dentistry since the introduction of the government's new NHS dental contract in April 2006.

The figures, according to Susie Sanderson, chair of the British Dental Association's executive board, were "further evidence of the persisting problems with the 2006 NHS dental reforms". But look a little closer. There were 655 more dentists doing NHS work in 2007-2008 than there were in the previous year, an increase of 3.2 per cent. NHS dental treatments also rose last year by nearly one million, to 36 million. And while Sanderson and her organisation attack the government for introducing a "crude, target-driven system", there is growing evidence that the BDA's members don't share this disdain.

The government's chief dental officer, Dr Barry Cockcroft, cites the example of Cornwall Primary Care Trust, which, when asking for tenders for four new NHS practices, received more than 80 applicants. "When primary care trusts ask for tenders for new services, dentists are falling over themselves to bid for them," he says.

It seems that some dentists are deciding that the NHS contracts, which provide dentists with a guaranteed salary of roughly £80,000 a year for three years and a 5 per cent reduction in their workload, are not such a bad deal after all. The economic slowdown could also be helping the return of dentists to the fold. Dr Mark Harris was among 2,000 to resign from the NHS prior to the introduction of the new contracts. Now he has applied to Devon Primary Care Trust to provide NHS care for adults at his Totnes practice. "I think when there isn't much money about, the best arrangement is a mixture of NHS and private work," he admits.

The dramatic decline of NHS dentistry can be traced to the decision of John Major's government to cut the fees payable to NHS dentists in the early 1990s - something to remember during the current wave of nostalgia for the former Conservative prime minister. The decision led to an exodus of dentists from the NHS into private practice. In 1990, before the cuts, only 5 per cent of dentists' earnings came from the private sector; today it accounts for more than half. And as private practice has grown, so the overriding commitment of the dental profession and its governing body to the NHS has weakened.

Throughout the 1990s, one could not question the fervency of the BDA's support for the NHS, but today the emphasis appears to have changed. In her speech to the BDA's May conference in Manchester, Sanderson enthused over the merits of private dentistry. "For many [here], private dentistry has given you the opportunity to work the way you want to, without any sense of compromise," she said. "It has given you freedom." She went on to express scepticism as to whether the NHS could ever meet the "expectations of patients and users".

It is hard not to detect a certain air of defeatism - Sanderson claimed last year that the future of NHS dentistry was "increasingly fragile" - and the BDA's disenchantment with NHS reforms has been seized upon by those opposed to the very idea of NHS care. In its own words, Nurses for Reform, a pro-privatisation pressure group, wants "to see NHS dentistry totally collapse".
"We want customers to be angry at how little they are getting for their taxation, and we want them to defect to a burgeoning private dental sector," writes the group's director, Dr Helen Evans, whose anti-NHS polemic Who Cares for the NHS? was published by the Institute of Economic Affairs earlier this year. "Already, in many [politicians'] minds, the NHS is dead," Evans claimed, having previously described the service as a "Stalinist embarrassment".

Open wide (your wallet)

The favoured gambit of the private dentistry lobby is to make NHS dentistry seem like a lost cause and the complete privatisation of dental care inevitable. If this all sounds familiar, then cast your mind back to the early 1990s when the same "the system's so broke it can't be mended" arguments were made by free-market think tanks lobbying for British Rail's denationalisation.

But nothing is inevitable until it happens - and there is nothing inevitable about the demise of NHS dentistry. The return of dentists to the NHS fold is a fact that fits neither Nurses for Reform nor the BDA's doom-laden prognosis. The increased number of places for training NHS dentists also gives grounds for optimism, as does the government's decision to increase funding for NHS dentistry by 11 per cent next year. And all three main parties remain formally committed to increasing provision.

In the final analysis, the future of NHS dentistry will be guaranteed only if voters raise their voices to urge that more resources be spent on improving access to the service. And the importance of expanding NHS dentistry cannot be overestimated if we care about both our teeth and our wallets: the decline in NHS provision over the past two decades has led to a major deterioration in the nation's oral health. In some parts of the country, tooth decay rose by 50 per cent between 1993 and 2003; mouth cancer has risen by around 25 per cent, with more than 4,700 new cases being diagnosed in the UK each year. The replacement of NHS dentistry with a wholly private system, as free-market pressure groups desire, would prove as catastrophic as the privatisation of the railways has been.

If we want to know what a Britain without any NHS dentistry would be like, we need only look to the United States, where more than 100 million people are without dental insurance and 27 per cent of children and 29 per cent of adults have cavities that go untreated. Last year, a child in Mississippi and another in Maryland died from infections caused by decayed teeth.

When the NHS was formed, exactly 60 years ago this summer, it promised to provide "all medical, dental and nursing care". Free NHS dental care may only have lasted until 1951 - the first year that NHS charges were introduced - but for more than 40 years the NHS provided Britons with access to good-quality and affordable dental treatment. The question that needs to be asked of the free-market ideologues who are already gleefully writing its epitaph is a simple one: if Britain could afford - and operate - a comprehensive NHS dental system in the austerity years of the 1940s and the recession-hit 1970s, why on earth can't we do the same today?

We'll know for sure that we've stopped the rot when dentist jokes are once again about extracting teeth, and not extracting money.

6 comments:

Roland Hulme said...

Ha! Ironic.

I lived in England for most of my life and was simply unable to afford (or find) dental care in England. It was so bad that I hadn't seen a dentist in FIFTEEN YEARS until I moved to America.

In America, I pay $10 a month and have outstanding work by a brilliant dentist. I do have to pay 'co-pay'... And for my recent gum work, it worked out to be 25% of what I'd have had to pay to get the same service done by an NHS dentist if I'd had the inexplicable fortitude to find one.

The NHS dental system is an example what what the NHS health system will soon become.

Neil Clark said...

Hi Roland,
I'm pleased things have worked out well for you dentistry-wise in the US, but millions of Americans are not so fortunate. I agree with you that NHS charges are too high - the points you make back up the case that in Britain we need more NHS dentistry- not less- and we want much lower NHS charges- or ideally getting rid of NHS dental charges all together and going back to the situation as it existed in 1948. If we could operate an affordable and comprehensive NHS dental system in the 50s, 60s and 70s, why can't we do it now?

Roland Hulme said...

Hi Neil,

I think the answer to your question is the same reason we can't run an effective NHS!

Although I will give you this: I don't think it's socialism or nationalism to blame. It's mismanagement OF that nationalized entity. Too many 'managers' and too few doctors.

That's why I think private industry could streamline things.

That being said, I just forked out a disgusting amount of 'co pay' for the birth of our son. I'd have been horrified - if my local NHS maternity ward back in England hadn't had two sepsis deaths in the same ward.

You get what you pay for?

Anonymous said...

Hmmm, now is clear to me, why we have here so many dental tourist from UK. They say that even when they pay plane ticket and hotel stay it is cheaper to do teeth in Belgrade than in UK!

But still we have the same problem here in Serbia. We don't have dental insurance. I am for weeks delaying small dental operation, because 100 euros for that procedure, is too much for me, as is for average Serb.

Nick said...

I am always slightly bemused by complaints that NHS dentistry is too expensive. I'm an NHS 'lifer' (I'm now 30) and through the simple expediency of brushing twice a day and regular flossing I have avoided having major work done on my teeth. I have no fillings, no caps, no bridges and no gum surgery - nor have I (yet) had to have my wisdom teeth removed. Doubtless the generally good quality of tap water - with added fluoride - has also helped. Consequently, paying £15 every six months - when I usually have a bit of extra cleaning and plaque removal done - seems a bit of a bargain. Although I am now living in the US I hope to be able to book my dental appointments to coincide with return visits to the UK. Of course people have a right to expect a reasonable degree of free healthcare if they've paid National Insurance - but we bear more responsibility for the health of our own teeth than dentists.

Teeth Whitening said...

oh my god i hate wisdom teeth, i swear i thought my jaw was going to fall out and i was going to drop dead and die of pain!

Great post!

Cheers,
Brody