Saturday, September 02, 2006

The Not So Good Good List

Yesterday, the Independent published its' Good List 2006'- a listing of 'fifty men and women who make our world a better place'.
There's a few names with whom it's hard to take issue with, such as Sir David Attenborough and the saintly Monsignor Bruce Kent. But some of the other choices leave a lot to be desired. "Few have done more to fight the death penalty in the US than the British lawyer Clive Stafford-Smith", the Independent announces- without asking what right does an British lawyer have to lecture Americans on how they deal with their murderers? Bishop of Oxford Richard Harries is lauded for condemning the Iraq war, but supporting 'the war in the Balkans'- presumably for the 'moralist' Bishop- and the Independent, the lives of innocent Serbs are of lesser account than innocent Iraqis.
Shirley Williams and Chris Patten, two of the most disastrous and accident-prone politicians of the post-war era are also included as is Bob Geldof, the clapped out, foul-mouthed pop star who became a multi-millionaire businessman by exhorting the poor in the rich countries to hand over their fxxxing money to the rich in poor countries.
Other ludicrous choices include Anne Owers ,the Inspector of Prisons who doesn't believe in prisons, and the tiresome self-publicist Peter Tatchell who believed the British government should have armed Shi-ite militia in an attempt to overthrow Saddam in 2003.
Instead of Stafford-Smith, Williams, Harries, Patten, Owers and Tatchell- what about Pilger, Benn (Tony, not Hilary), Hitchens (Peter, not Christopher), Berners-Lee (the modest and self-effacing inventor of the World Wide Web) and last, but not least the wholly admirable Jimmy Perry and David Croft -who with their classic comedies have done more to put a smile on people's faces than most of the Indie's 'good' men and women put together.
What do you think?

5 comments:

davidr1534 said...

So Neil, we can not complain about the actions of a state on its citizens, even when it kills them? I thought the left tended to eschew absolute soveriegnty - long live international solidarity!

1defender said...

Have just watched "Should we negotiate with Al Qaeda?" on BBC2 this evening. In the course of the programme two bombers were known to have trained in Bosnia. Seeing pictures of Iraq today I cannot but look back on Iraq as it was before the US/UK invasion. It was a secular state. It was also the cradle of our collective civilisation. It is now in ruins. it is unbelieveable that there is still no public recognition that the wars in Bosnia and now in Kosovo have contributed to the terrorist violence in Iraq. Unbelieveable!

Anonymous said...

This sad post simply underscores the bitterness, Neil, that you clearly feel at being passed over for entry into this pantheon of left wing halfwits.
How's the traffic at your site, by the way. I haven't been here for months!

Neil Clark said...

Yeh, right, anonymous- I feel absolutely gutted at being left off the Independent's list....

Praguetory said...

Neil - I have to say it's nice to see a Leftie eschewing the anti-capital punishment knee-jerk. This list is an absolute joke and has been attacked splendidly by Dizzy Thinks.